Pages

Reasonable



Since the time of the enlightenment, western thinkers (in the tradition of the Greeks) have tended toward the assumption that certain ways of reasoning are universal in scope. Among Christian laity, often when hearing a scholar speak of cultural context, development of dogmatism or other such interpretation related necessities, some could assume the scholar is undermining the text or claiming it to be somehow false or insufficient. What fails to be understood is what we consider “reasonable” is influenced by our own worldviews, which have been shaped by our historical understanding, culture, economics, traditions, denomination and/or religions affiliations. Our perception of the world and derivation of what constitutes “reasonable” is radically different than someone on the other side of the world, who could take the same words or data and arrive at an opposite conclusion. For example, a British individual when expressing excitement regarding his accommodations or apartment may say, “I’m mad about my flat”, while an American would take that to mean, he got stuck somewhere due to lack of sufficient tire air pressure on an automobile. We cannot interpret the Bible with a modern set of cultural paradigms, axioms or personal idealism. Translation is by nature interpretation; interpretation is often biased.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Ground-rules for comments:
1) Identify yourself by observing social decorum and use your real name.
2) Please stick to the subject of the post. Introducing extraneous issues makes it confusing for everyone.
3) Relevant queries, informed comments and disagreement are welcomed, but don't use this as a soap-box to vent your pet views or to simply to be obnoxious.
4) State your query concisely and make your comment with regard for other readers.
5) Be honorable and avoid insults and slurs, and focus on engagement with the issues and data. Comments with personal attacks or insults will not be tolerated. Refutation, declaring an error, all welcome and appropriate, but keep it polite and fair.